Everything Wrong With Fight Club In 11 Minutes Or Less

*This video is a re-upload. Original release date: 9/25/14*
Also, TV Sins here: jpgo.info/tv-e4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
Oh yes we did. It's been almost 4 years. Time to put our money where our motto is. So here are the sins of the much beloved and respected (with good reason) Citizen Kane.

Patreon: www.patreon.com/CinemaSins
Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
TVSins: jpgo.info/tv-e4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
MusicVideoSins: jpgo.info
Jeremy: cinemasins
Barrett: musicvideosins
Aaron: aarondicer
Jonathan: samloomis13

Subreddit: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
Website: cinemasins.com
SinCast Facebook page: SinCastCinemaSins
Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store


  1. CinemaSins

    CinemaSins年 前

    Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We’ll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday for the next few months. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday and Thursday!

  2. Jeffrey Jackson

    Jeffrey Jackson13 日 前

    k ? .., .j .

  3. Daniel Lugo

    Daniel Lugo25 日 前

    What's with the last 3 minutes?

  4. Anonymous Anonymous

    Anonymous Anonymous4 ヶ月 前

    he's coming back from the building they vandalized this is where they started hinting they're the same person at 7:00

  5. GDI

    GDI6 ヶ月 前

    life insurance pays funeral expenses i think



    Citizen Kane???

  7. Keep The Hope Running

    Keep The Hope Running日 前

    If you payed attention lmao you would know that the urine did go into the soup because they mention a lawsuit later in the movie

  8. Dwayne Earl James

    Dwayne Earl James4 日 前

    I have to stop watching these idiots try to mock great movies. Go make fun of Goonies...nobody gives a shit. But films like this? F*** you.

  9. Jay

    Jay6 日 前

    Fight club is a kickass movie and can never be replaced at #1 spot where it will stay forever!(I watch it every year/month and everytime the power/wifi goes out because I have it downloaded to where its an easy find and watchable offline..arent I smart?(No..not really, just for this I am)

  10. Ben Flood

    Ben Flood7 日 前

    the pepsi shit is gutting. removes any and all weight that this movie had for 14 year old me.

  11. Adan Robles

    Adan Robles8 日 前

    Most of the the things that are listed as a “sin” is just you talking shit about the movies, “ otherwise this video would have been about 3 min long

  12. · ·

    · ·9 日 前

    Club penguin

  13. · ·

    · ·9 日 前


  14. Jack Scotchland

    Jack Scotchland14 日 前


  15. Maxy

    Maxy14 日 前

    <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="476">7:56</a> well, not anymore

  16. Dat Wolfe

    Dat Wolfe14 日 前

    never noticed the guy show up at <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="57">0:57</a>

  17. Raining Lands

    Raining Lands16 日 前

    anyone else notice the man flashing by quickly next to the doctor?

  18. dpsamu2000

    dpsamu200016 日 前

    You think this delusional, unreliable narrator is telling the truth about screwing Marla? Does Marla even exist? Or fight club even? So this whole movie is the common fantasy of dull drones wanting to be the most important man in the world. Can't understand any way to do it but by violence because they're dull drones. Wonder why it's so popular with dull drones who've made nothing of their lives? Think fans of this movie work in offices, and own IKIA furniture? No. Those are the bosses they despise. So the movie is full of movie cliches huh? What else are dull drones going to base their fantasies of violent world conquest on? Not like they remember much of their high school calculus and quantum mechanics now do they?

  19. Big Boi

    Big Boi16 日 前

    Come on you forgot about taking a sin off for the end before I even watched the video I almost knew that you would say “Man that is one hell of an ending” Then the video would end

  20. Alex Adlington

    Alex Adlington19 日 前

    How do you know he wasn't more than just the 2 characters that were revealed? It would explain a few issues you bring up. (Explaining fighting self to strangers, all those people in one house, knowing when to answer questions, etc)

  21. Ricardo Pereira

    Ricardo Pereira22 日 前

    cool ? cool, bro. Good idea.

  22. Wood 'n' Stuff w/ Steve French

    Wood 'n' Stuff w/ Steve French23 日 前

    @<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="198">3:18</a> - I've looked and looked and looked and do not see little dots. Also, Fight Club sucked ass. My family and I finally watched it a few months ago to see what all the hype is about (because for years I've heard countless "The first rule of X is that you don't talk about X" references in movies, shows, real life, etc...). We hated it. Same thing with 2001: A Space Odyssey. How are these movies so beloved by so many? They fucking SUCK!!!

  23. Quattro

    Quattro23 日 前

    The insurance payment on the flight is a depiction of the narrator job. Not his the thought that he'd get a paid out more for a death.

  24. Quattro

    Quattro23 日 前

    Marla singer showing up to his support group is what sparks this movie.

  25. Uncle Anon

    Uncle Anon23 日 前

    There is absolutely nothing wrong with this movie. Every pixel, every sound is plain perfect.

  26. TheRealDamiani

    TheRealDamiani24 日 前

    How dare you judge this masterpiece! Blasphemy!!!!

  27. Marcus Aplin

    Marcus Aplin24 日 前

    Audio outtakes-Under the Bridge by Red Hot Chili Peppers playing with Edward Norton running in slow motion= Discount Anthony Kiedis and his slow mo stroll from the music vid! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

  28. The imperialist Historian

    The imperialist Historian25 日 前

    I just watched this a hour ago on a separate device and now JPgo is recommending this to me wtf???

  29. Charles Horvath

    Charles Horvath26 日 前

    Nearly every nit picking seen shown is explained by the fact the narrator is hallucinating with a personality disorder. Pretty dumb video.

  30. Spoot

    Spoot26 日 前

    I watch this movie often while on flights.

  31. Kenosha Tire

    Kenosha Tire26 日 前

    This movie is depressing and hate-able to me. Was when I saw it in high school on opening night and it remains so to me today. IMO you could win the lottery and then watch this movie and think "Life sucks". It's that downtrodden and uninspiring. I don't mind a bit of a dark thriller but Fight Club just seemed like it aimed to put people in bad moods. It tries to hard to be edgy and have a "societal message" but I didn't want or need to hear that message.

  32. Julian Baxter

    Julian Baxter26 日 前

    Humming birds are very quiet. They could be right next to ur ear and u wouldn't know it. So the line makes sense and ur sin has officially been absolved.

  33. Soldier31Bang

    Soldier31Bang27 日 前

    Didnt watch this yes but it better have “main character has two personalities cliche”

  34. philip kemp

    philip kemp28 日 前

    Came here for the sin comments Ding!

  35. Eamon Moore

    Eamon Moore29 日 前

    Fact of the matter is nothing in this movie makes sense with the reveal and if you want to say that's due to an unreliable narrator that's fine but it's dumb. Same thing with Joker, it works to a point, but at some point it becomes too abstract to follow. It's still a good movie but it's far from the best movie to be on CinemaSins

  36. E M

    E M29 日 前

    This is a terrible analysis. Couldn’t get through it.

  37. Dawn Andalan

    Dawn Andalanヶ月 前

    I still love this movie

  38. RapedByRepublicansII

    RapedByRepublicansIIヶ月 前

    It's true I think the film was good on its own merits but so many of the things that made a lot of sense in the book they sort of jam them together so they would work for the picture and with a book like this that's hard to do... Yeah yeah they do that with every book-to-movie translation typically but unfortunately this is one of those books that if you cut a few things out here or there, things really start to not make sense. For instance, one of the things it says when Tyler is getting fired from the projectionists job, more so than he actually did the change overs for the projections I'd that he cut the things down to be sent around to the various distribution houses and then he packed them together and vice versa that is in the old days a film was on six or seven reels but that most modern theaters it's just one real so that in fact a large part of his job is really editing more so than actually changing over pictures anyway there's a bunch of that shit if you read the book I'm not going to comment on any more of it and I don't expect you to know it but hey... I feel like if you take knowledge of the novel in with you you'll get where the movie fudges things and it still makes sense

  39. RapedByRepublicansII

    RapedByRepublicansIIヶ月 前

    It kind of looks like it kept her number purposely unburned reminds me exactly of how that 911 guys passport was somehow found in the street haha

  40. Eric Heitner

    Eric Heitnerヶ月 前

    www.jackdurden.com The above website explains everything about the movie that you just tore apart. Very interesting to read it. Basically says that he is all the characters and that each “person” is really just a personality of his.

  41. thelordofhellaz

    thelordofhellazヶ月 前

    Oops.....Jared Leto isn't the only one with an Oscar now :-)

  42. Karthik Mahesh

    Karthik Maheshヶ月 前

    That last scene of shooting inside his mouth would have take out half of his face. it is not just the bullet but the huge amount of energy and explosive gases that are released.

  43. Little Boy

    Little Boyヶ月 前

    The constant products like Pepsi and Starbucks are comments on the irony of the movie itself. It’s a film about consumerism but is ultimately dragged down by the same things. Because “Fight Club” the movie is just another consumer product that’s made to make money. That’s the genius of it.

  44. NRepic

    NRepicヶ月 前

    Actually yes, Marla is the only reason why this whole thing happened. She interrupted his meetings... ie, his lie. She actually has feelings for him and because of that she is constantly challenging his alter ego. Which is why Tyler tries to get rid of her. The only reason why he is in that very spot in the way he is, realizing the mess he made is because of her. Otherwise he would have gone and stayed at the meeting probably for the rest of his life. How can you even missed that. I don't like to teardown channels but please get your damn info right. Even if you are going to "jokingly do it" do with some kind credibility.

  45. CalpolMeister

    CalpolMeisterヶ月 前

    Half of the sins for inconsistensy are literally the point of the film but we move

  46. Jon

    Jonヶ月 前

    A jerry can holds over 4 gallons, there looks like theres more than 100 jerry cans in the back.

  47. milchen fox

    milchen foxヶ月 前

    I just watchey because our Chemistry teacher showed us the soap making part in class aka the hand burning part. Was a great lesson

  48. Brendan Whelan

    Brendan Whelanヶ月 前

    I just don't buy into this movie. Soooo he had that level of schizophrenia and was talking to himself in every scene with Brad Pitt, and hears him having sex in other areas of the house? So he was downstairs and upstairs at the same time? Also him beating himself up in front of those guys and they don't say anything???? It's just not believable. Also a Norton narrating and looking at the camera? Awful. How did this movie get such praise?

  49. Scraffy

    Scraffyヶ月 前

    The book explains why he pisses in the soups. To get back at the richer upper class, the book is about uprising socialist class systems with controlled anarchy.

  50. Edgar Jiménez Núñez

    Edgar Jiménez Núñezヶ月 前

    This movie has no sins cmon

  51. Matilde Ruivo

    Matilde Ruivoヶ月 前

    After watching this movie I'm still confused. How did the narrator called Tyler after the building exploded if he is Tyler??

  52. Axolotl In Spirit

    Axolotl In Spiritヶ月 前


  53. Joze Greinch

    Joze Greinchヶ月 前

    you randomly add sins... I wish sins where more objective

  54. Sylvia-Novella Underwood

    Sylvia-Novella Underwoodヶ月 前

    What if the main character was actually suffering from some form of schizophrenia or split personality disorder

  55. Sylvia-Novella Underwood

    Sylvia-Novella Underwoodヶ月 前

    This movie is so nihilistic I love it

  56. Anthony Wandowicz

    Anthony Wandowiczヶ月 前

    Lowest count ive seen so far

  57. MYREAPER23

    MYREAPER23ヶ月 前


  58. Ryan Ortega

    Ryan Ortegaヶ月 前

    Brad won it now, though

  59. Ryan Ortega

    Ryan Ortegaヶ月 前

    Original line in book, “I wanna have your abortion.”

  60. Rudol Von Stroheim

    Rudol Von Stroheimヶ月 前

    You made like 3 really good points and the rest... i need to read the novel again since its been like ten years and see what was changed to make a movie flow better



    That final sin was the only sin this movie had tbh

  62. The Corned Beef Council

    The Corned Beef Councilヶ月 前

    These sins are incredibly weak. A lot of Fight Club is not supposed to make sense, you see it from the Narrators point of view. I don’t think you’ve understood anything about this film.

  63. trumpetperson11

    trumpetperson11ヶ月 前

    <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="145">2:25</a> He is imagining he stole the car, because that's subconsciously what he wants to do. Notice how after Tyler steals the car you don't get any more of that POV. That is because he never actually did it, and so there is no POV to go to.

  64. Zhane Fulp

    Zhane Fulpヶ月 前

    Sin: "No wonder this movie lost to this other movie at the 1999 domestic box office" cliche

  65. Casey Riley

    Casey Rileyヶ月 前

    Everything wrong with cinema sins video about everything wrong with fight club

  66. kenwes69

    kenwes69ヶ月 前

    400 gallons in van totally possible however 3000 lbs.

  67. Violent Syn

    Violent Synヶ月 前

    <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="57">0:57</a>

  68. Gavin Veilleux

    Gavin Veilleuxヶ月 前

    Dont over pick apart a movie you're supposed to pick apart

  69. isabella maselli

    isabella maselliヶ月 前

    Marla has something major to do with the ending of the film, thought. "Jack" sees Tyler since the beginning of the movie but it's not the embodiment of what Tyler represents yet. Jack was in a sense cured from insomnia thanks to support groups and he says that he could sleep again until Marla shows up and he can't sleep again. That's when all the Tyler Durden story starts. Marla is the trigger that causes his splitting into Tyler, also because of the idea of relationship with women society imposes on men. Jack is torn in his relationship with Marla between his loving self and the violent, Tyler, self, who sees women as objects as the society wants him to see them. Jack is intoxicated by society and ideas of toxic masculinity which Tyler embodies.

  70. L

    L2 ヶ月 前

    In the book, Marla's line goes, "I haven't been fucked like that since kindergarten," which is framed as a gross joke. I actually think the "censored" version in the movie achieves the intended dark humor better because, given Marla's character, you're nudged into believing that what she said might be sincere. Yikes.

  71. adeline stoten

    adeline stoten2 ヶ月 前

    this movie sucks lol

  72. pork fang

    pork fang2 ヶ月 前

    Ugh! He imagined Tyler....

  73. mistamontiel00

    mistamontiel002 ヶ月 前

    <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="525">8:45</a> grammar sin @ it's -.-

  74. Crawl

    Crawl2 ヶ月 前

    this was such a stupid movie that inspired a lot of idiots to do this same crap!

  75. Kurt Go Bangz

    Kurt Go Bangz2 ヶ月 前

    m.jpgo.info/bideo/hqubyqiVmajTqqw.html A fight club instrumental🔥🔥🔥

  76. Ooh

    Ooh2 ヶ月 前

    You are such a marvel guy

  77. saar144

    saar1442 ヶ月 前

    Most overrated movie ever.

  78. chentaurski

    chentaurski2 ヶ月 前

    One of the most overrated movies in the history. The whole fucking thing doesn't make sense.

  79. The Blue Quasar

    The Blue Quasar2 ヶ月 前

    <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="110">1:50</a> That’s not how life insurance works 😜

  80. Charles Gushue

    Charles Gushue2 ヶ月 前

    UPDATE: Brad Pitt now has an Oscar too. :D

  81. TheRiddick27

    TheRiddick272 ヶ月 前

    Where's he been to end up going back home to see his 'Fight Club' has expanded? Isn't it obvious? He was setting up more FC franchises in other states. He's obviously got mental health issues so it never bothered me he is both f**king Marla Singer AND doin' signups. He could also be losing track of what he does and when. Again, due to his issues. The only thing that ever did bother me was jackoffs who thought this was a film about fight clubs.

  82. SlowHands

    SlowHands2 ヶ月 前

    You forgot the first rule......

  83. Dan Outdoors

    Dan Outdoors2 ヶ月 前

    The grade school line was a change, the original line was apparently meant to be "I want to have your abortion" but that was to much....

  84. Ignis Ursulus

    Ignis Ursulus2 ヶ月 前

    Half of these sins were assigned because you're expecting an insane man's experience of time and how his two lives interract to follow sanity and logic. I'm no expert on schizophrenia, but I'm pretty sure that he can remember things that he did in the past as if he was hearing the other Tyler do them in real time

  85. olof

    olof2 ヶ月 前

    Choose your words very wisely, old man.