Everything Wrong With Star Wars Episode IV A New Hope - With Kevin Smith

*This video is a re-upload. Original release date: 11/26/15*
Also, TV Sins here: jpgo.info/tv-e4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
Finally, after three years of requests, we take on Star Wars. But with the help of geek god Kevin Smith, which seemed only appropriate given the man's credibility AND his professed love of Cinema Sins. So sit back, strap in, and get ready for sin hyperdrive.

Patreon: www.patreon.com/CinemaSins
Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
TVSins: jpgo.info/tv-e4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
MusicVideoSins: jpgo.info
Jeremy: cinemasins
Barrett: musicvideosins
Aaron: aarondicer
Jonathan: samloomis13

Subreddit: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
Website: cinemasins.com
SinCast Facebook page: SinCastCinemaSins
Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store


  1. CinemaSins

    CinemaSins5 ヶ月 前

    Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We’ll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday for the next few months. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday and Thursday!

  2. TheDba82

    TheDba8212 日 前

    Great, loved this one.

  3. NotoriousJASS

    NotoriousJASS2 ヶ月 前

    Too bad you kept the shitty Kevin figure around, what an ignorant, racist bigot. He talks as if he's from the hood. He's white, he's not.

  4. Crashburn 32

    Crashburn 323 ヶ月 前

    Why is Kevin Smith doing a Nick Nolte impression through the whole video?

  5. Joseph Muir

    Joseph Muir3 ヶ月 前

    Kevin Smith, or whatever his name is, absolutely ruins this. Redo one without him!

  6. Rust Base Builder

    Rust Base Builder3 ヶ月 前

    CinemaSins I love your channel but Kevin smith ruined this video

  7. Juan Morris

    Juan Morris時間 前

    Robot Chicken pointed out the biggest eww: Luke crying over Obi-wan, a guy he barely knew. Versus Leia loosing; that favorite tree she climbed as a kid, the favorite candy store she often visited, her cousins, the elementary - jr or highschool she attended, her classmates, her house, her mom, her dad, those annoying parlay vous fran-say a**holes on the other side of the planet -- oh wait. Her PLANET! Leia should have been catatonically inconsolable by comparison! [No problem with the French, just bagging on the reasonless dislike jokes]

  8. Funtime Foxy Games

    Funtime Foxy Games11 時間 前

    Infinity sins. Why? Bad choice adding Kevin Smith. That’s all I have to say

  9. Paul Chappel

    Paul Chappel17 時間 前

    Love your videos, but you missed a HUGE sin. After they leave the Death Star, Leia puts a blanket around Luke to console him for the death of Obi-Wan, his best friend and mentor of about three days. Just before they arrived, Leia watched her planet with her adoptive parents, siblings, if any, friends, and just every fricking person she's ever known as it became an asteroid field. Don't you think she might have needed a blankie, too? I'd add five sins, for no particular reason.

  10. GerudoKing

    GerudoKing日 前

    Length of movie sinning with Kevin Smith: 18 minutes, 42 seconds Length of movie sinning without Kevin Smith: probably 11 or 12 minutes Look, Chasing Amy was great, but that kind of humor doesn't need to pad out the length of a Cinemasins video.

  11. NWAWskeptic

    NWAWskeptic2 日 前

    Release a special edition sins of this movie, and remove Kevin Smith entirely

  12. purgruv

    purgruv3 日 前

    Who is this awful Kevin Smith cunt?

  13. DjTruchas

    DjTruchas3 日 前


  14. Ryan Rose

    Ryan Rose3 日 前

    no, i doutt luke wanted to meet actorians. He was seeing a cute Twilek girl

  15. punkoid76

    punkoid764 日 前

    Was going to complain about Kevin Smith, but thousands beat me to it...

  16. Lady Onikara

    Lady Onikara2 日 前

    They sure did.

  17. SpetZemas

    SpetZemas5 日 前

    Fucking hell who is that guy taking 7 years to present a sin?

  18. Larry Kin

    Larry Kin5 日 前

    Only Imperial Stormtroopers are so precise. Oh yeah,and Kevin Smith.

  19. Shaykh Ra'id

    Shaykh Ra'id5 日 前

    But how did Luke's photon torpedoes turn and go down the hole?

  20. daro2096

    daro20966 日 前

    Hands up if you have ever watched the prequel trilogy and the sequel trilogy more than once? I mean all three films one after another. Yes, I know episode 9 hasn't been released yet. I haven't.

  21. Gridseeker

    Gridseeker7 日 前

    Haters: Disney cannon is crapp, nothing beats the superior writting of the original trilogy. This video: hold my beer.

  22. Hawk66100

    Hawk661007 日 前

    Kevin Smith is the man and an avid Star Wars fan. I can’t believe so many people are hating on him.

  23. Jordan Turtle

    Jordan Turtle6 日 前

    because he talks too much

  24. Adrian metzler-holden

    Adrian metzler-holden8 日 前

    Hahahahaha!! Wil-storm helm-trooper. So good.

  25. fujimi715

    fujimi7158 日 前

    The Kevin smith guy made this unwatchable. Please dont ever have him on your videos again

  26. Ethan Winters

    Ethan Winters8 日 前

    No, no, no, light speed is too slow! We're gonna have to go right to... Ludicrous Speed!"

  27. August Life

    August Life9 日 前

    Never do sins with Kevin Smith again.

  28. Joseph Viggiano

    Joseph Viggiano9 日 前

    Turned off the video about 1/3 of the way through cuz Kevin Smith's commentary had me on the verge of blowing my brains out

  29. G T

    G T9 日 前

    Luke could not see in the helmet because it was the wrong size

  30. G T

    G T9 日 前

    Parsects mean distance not time

  31. hello there

    hello there10 日 前

    The red droid at 2:54 from what I heard the droid knew about luke saving the galaxy or whatever so the red droid made his power converter explode or whatever so luke will pick r2 d2 the red droid might of known about r2 d2 and what r2 d2 had on him

  32. ShamockParticle

    ShamockParticle11 日 前

    The 2nd narrator is an interesting experiment; I liked Smith's input for this video.

  33. EduSmart

    EduSmart11 日 前

    Errrr this Kevin Smith really isn't adding anything to this, just incredibly annoying, couldn't watch this post all the way through, and that is a first for Cinema Sins!!!

  34. 19maikel86

    19maikel8611 日 前

    R2-D2 is just a driving usb connector..

  35. Andrew Boccasino

    Andrew Boccasino11 日 前

    Jeremy I sin you for not showing Princess Leigh’s reveal. From when Han, Luke, and Chewy rescue Princess Leigh from her cell in the Death Star. Classic scene that in my opinion deserved to be shown. R.I.P. Carrie Fisher.

  36. Chef Dean

    Chef Dean11 日 前

    Of course no one thought two people with Kenobi for a last name were related . . . That's Racist !

  37. Ayush Khandelwal

    Ayush Khandelwal11 日 前

    Am I the only one who outlaughed Jeremy when Obi Wan called stormtrooper aim accurate?

  38. Man Falls

    Man Falls14 日 前

    That chicken guy from Al's Toy Barn on the bottom left corner of the screen made this video 20 minutes long.

  39. Crock in A cup

    Crock in A cup14 日 前

    Kevin Smith is so annoying I mean I can’t blame the guy I don’t want to be offensive I mean you can’t have an annoying voice in the video but I’m pretty sure he’s a very very nice guy in real life

  40. Patrick Stowell

    Patrick Stowell14 日 前

    One sin I think you forgot: the fact that hitting that thermal exhaust port and destroying the Death Star was presented as a challenge in any way. Like, Star Wars has all this advanced technology, but guided munitions? No. BUT WAIT, Jango Fett had guided missiles BEFORE THE F*CKING CLONE WAR STARTED. But yes, lets use dumb torpedoes to hit this amazing flaw. Brilliant. Also, "Great shot kid, that was one in a million!!" Uh, no. It was one in two. Literally one other guy tried shooting this stupid thing before Luke went and did the "impossible". I love the sh*t out of this movie, and this franchise, but you could fly a Star Destroyer taped to a Sandcrawler through some of these plot-holes.

  41. Mike S

    Mike S15 日 前

    Spoiler: 4 years later and Kevin Smith still sucks ass at narrating this re-uploaded video.

  42. Paul Essenson

    Paul Essenson16 日 前


  43. Ken Coakley

    Ken Coakley17 日 前

    How about the sin of Luke Skywalker screaming "No" when Darth Vader kills Obi Wan Kenobi, ruining a chance at a silent getaway. As for Chewbacca not getting a medal, in Star Wars canon wookies don't believe in medals or any kind of award or commendations.

  44. sean brown

    sean brown17 日 前

    Obi wan is a complete dick to Luke in all the original films telling him half truths and outright lies "from a certain point of view". If I was Luke I would have felt so betrayed I would have joined Vader. At least he never lied to Luke.

  45. sean brown

    sean brown17 日 前

    Kevin ruined this

  46. Dee Lem

    Dee Lem19 日 前

    "Except Gary, Indiana of course". I live there asshole but still laughing my ass off.

  47. Angel Lush

    Angel Lush19 日 前

    There is nothing wrong with the original trilogy

  48. TheCheetah

    TheCheetah20 日 前

    he sounds like a sex offender

  49. Silvesther Lusion

    Silvesther Lusion21 日 前

    come on guys, don't do this. you're just giving George Lucas more ideas to change the movies further in the next release.. xD

  50. Origami

    Origami22 日 前

    idk why so many of you bitchez are crying. KS is funny as hell.

  51. Stuart Anderws

    Stuart Anderws24 日 前

    This should also be a SIN For me the solder that say "We have analysed there attack and there is a danger" was also a children's TV presenter on Playschool written for 2 to 5 year old. Me being 6 when this film came out really broke my immersion. Also in the next film the man in command that drops them out of light speed too close to the planet. He was the hatted deputy head teacher in a fiction TV school for 6 to 12 year old. So we all cheered when he dies 3 years latter. All right 1 sin off for that.

  52. Alex Solis

    Alex Solis24 日 前

    Just don’t sin Star Wars just don’t

  53. Eos Mark

    Eos Mark25 日 前

    I don't get it at 7:13

  54. Monique East

    Monique East25 日 前

    Chewy’s medal is in his left hand

  55. Chris Christoforos

    Chris Christoforos26 日 前

    Chewbacca won the medal of outliving everyone in that scene.

  56. ian liam

    ian liam26 日 前

    you misspelled HOMIE

  57. Anakin Skywalker

    Anakin Skywalker26 日 前

    This Luke guy looks cool

  58. John Farlam

    John Farlam29 日 前

    You missed a sin where Han calls Jabba a human being in the hanger scene

  59. Rainbow Rover

    Rainbow Roverヶ月 前

    Oh dear God, please please please please do not have a guest reviewer on. Your voice and even more important, your delivery is unmatched. I like Kevin Smith but he was not suited for this project. Total failure. Two things that should be labeled as NEVER AGAIN: 1) Trump 2) Kevin Smith on Cinema Sins (total fuck up).

  60. Imperial Darkova

    Imperial Darkovaヶ月 前

    I must be in the minority but Kevin Smith's off tangent commentary had me rolling 🤣 this was great

  61. Dano1947

    Dano1947ヶ月 前

    Tanner judge: I did, what's your point? Solo was somewhat disappointing and a parsec is still a measure of distance, 3.27 light years.

  62. Jose Flores

    Jose Floresヶ月 前

    Jeremy only remake when?

  63. Zane Thederahn

    Zane Thederahnヶ月 前

    Chewie didn't get a medal because Wookies aparently don't believe in giving or receiving awards.

  64. Zane Thederahn

    Zane Thederahn22 日 前

    @Origami It's what I saw in a video on some Star Wars Channel I'm subbed to. Forget which one. I think it was called: "Why Chewie didn't get a medal."

  65. Origami

    Origami22 日 前


  66. Joann Kennedy

    Joann Kennedyヶ月 前

    You are sinning a groundbreaking masterpiece movie. You got balls.

  67. jjmfrees 123

    jjmfrees 123ヶ月 前

    “Rrrrrrrrr...where’s my medal?”

  68. Dano1947

    Dano1947ヶ月 前

    Kevin should stick to Silent Bob and directing.

  69. Dano1947

    Dano1947ヶ月 前

    I never understood the reference to the millennium falcon making the kessel run in less then 12 parsecs, a parsec is a measure of distance, not time and there are no short cuts in space.

  70. Tanner Judge

    Tanner Judgeヶ月 前

    Dano1947 Watch Solo